End of life : An unworthy and fratricidal law

The MPs have just adopted at its 3rd reading the proposed bill legalising assisted suicide and euthanasia. At each successive reading, the number of votes against the text has consistently increased — 199 votes against the bill at the 1st reading, 226 at the 2nd reading and 232 at the 3rd reading — thus revealing the growing isolation of its promoters and the fragility of the vacillating slim majority at the National Assembly and its inexistence at the Senate.

Despite these repeated alert signals, the executive is obstinately seeking to push through the bill whereas it is causing a persistent malaise with health workers, widespread concern in public opinion and profound reservations among parliamentarians themselves.

Presented as an exceptional device, the text in fact establishes a broadened access to administered death. It opens the way to practices extending well beyond end of life situations : patients could be considered as eligible with a life expectancy of several months, or even several years. Moreover it enables those suffering from intellectual deficiency to resort to it, as long as their discernment is not considered as "severely" diminished.

The access criteria as well as the specified cooling-off periods are indicative of abuse : 15 days maximum to examine a request, a mere 2 days cooling-off period for the patient. As of tomorrow, it could be quicker to obtain administered death than to achieve a multitude of everyday procedures.

By lifting the fundamental prohibition against killing, this law represents a major ethical breakdown : the overthrow of our commitment to solidarity, with all the entailing consequences :

  • Rejection of the universally accepted suicide prevention ;
  • Stigmatisation of the lives of the most vulnerable as being eligible for hastening ;
  • Divisions between health workers, within families and throughout society itself.

In the context of the heavy strain and fragility of the health system, at a time when isolation is on the increase and that so many of our fellow citizens have difficulty in accessing palliative care, this text sends a message of abandonment. It gives in to an individualist logic and medical omnipotence, by substituting a mortal outcome in place of accompaniment.

Tugdual Derville, the spokesman for Alliance VITA and author of "Docteur, ai-je le droit de vivre encore un peu ? (Doctor, have I the right to live a little longer) – Euthanasia and assisted suicide deciphered" (Salvator, 2023) reacted as follows : 

"The text adopted by MPs turns its back on the need for fraternity inscribed on the pediment of the French Republic. On this vital question, no society should accept that death could be proposed as a solution to the inadequacy of care and accompaniment. Renouncing the safety-first principle in such a sensitive domain constitutes a serious error by the executive and all those who support such an upheaval. That is the reason why we are steadfastly opposed to the process which the government is stubbornly hoping to push through before the summer recess, as if there were no other priorities for our nation."

Alliance VITA is solemnly calling on President Macron to appreciate the degree of the breakdown and to heed the numerous voices — from all sectors — warning of the human, medical and social dangers of such an upheaval.